top of page

Three Elections in India's Neighbourhood, Uncertain Outcomes

Representative Image
Representative Image

Elections without transformation projected for Myanmar, Bangladesh and Nepal with stability concerns continuing.

 

Stability within the countries and relations with Myanmar, Bangladesh and Nepal are of vital interest for India. The three countries are heading for polls with hopes of a new dawn, what are the predictions for stability ahead, here is a view.

 

Myanmar, Bangladesh and Nepal will be holding parliamentary polls in December 2025 [partial], February and March 2026 respectively.

 

The three neighbours of India have gone through a cataclysmic change led by violent movement in the case of Bangladesh [August 2024] and Nepal [September 2025] and a military coup in Myanmar [February 2021].

 

The degree of political disruption and security challenges have been varied ranging from collapse of law and order [Bangladesh and Nepal] to sparking a resistance movement [Myanmar].

 

While Bangladesh and Nepal have a tradition of electoral democracy though criticised by many, Myanmar was emerging into one after two series of polls seen as relatively free and fair in 2015 and 2020.

 

The disruptions led by a marginalized civil society in Dhaka and Kathmandu with elite capture and monopolization of government has set the stage for fresh polls. How free and fair these would be remains to be seen.

 

On the other hand in Myanmar, the Tatmadaw or the armed forces were feeling marginalized from power and thus usurped state authority in a move that is a replication of many military take over in the past.

 

Will the elections due in these three countries be free and fair and lead to a change, here is an assessment of key drivers-

 

Driver

Myanmar

Bangladesh

Nepal

Election Laws & Regulations

Structured by the military for exclusion of opposing forces

Degree of uncertainty prevails over implementation of the July Charter, planned referendum. Proportional representation (PR)

Positive

Election Commission

Union Election Commission controlled by the Tatmadaw

Election Commission credentials to be tested. 42,761 voting centres, 2,44,739 voting booths planned

Reasonably free and fair

Planning and Preparations for Elections

Ongoing

Ongoing

Just commenced

Multi Party Polls

Regulated participation with popular parties as the National League for Democracy [NLD] led by Aung Suu Kyi out of reckoning.

Positive but Awami League Banned

Positive

Political parties Approach

Parties selected by the miliary to participate, exclusionary

All parties participating less Awami League [Banned]

Participation by all parties confirmed less CPN UML – uncertain.

Unity of political approach

Directed by the military

Disputed and thus Negative

Under discussion largely negative

Factionalism within parties

Rampant but Controlled by military

Divide in Bangladesh Nationalist Party [BNP], National Citizens Party [NCP] Islamist and Left alliance. Jamaat e Islami showing unity

Horizontal cleavage in parties with demand for younger leadership to lead. Old versus the new divide to continue.

New political elements

Nil

NCP

Gen Z movement as a political block. Monarchists, victims of past violence and corruption.

Public attitude to elections

Resistance. Military enforcing participation through enactment of Election Protection Law which imposes harsh penalties for any criticism or complaints, with sentences ranging from three years in prison to the death penalty

Willingness to participate, however local and factional interests likely to lead to clashes.

Sceptical due to recent transformation, security and resistance by political elements, newbie elements in the Gen Z

Anticipated Polls Outcome

Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP) military supported party in lead support of Ma Ba Tha [Association for the Protection of Race and Religion], a Buddhist ultranationalist group leading

Cannot be determined

Cannot be determined

Security and Law and order

Challenged due to resistance by armed elements led by  National Unity Government and Ethnic Armed Organisations despite polls being held in phases based on control of constituencies by the military

High concerns due to culture of political violence, factional fighting within parties and disruptive elements.

67% of polling stations declared ‘risky’ by Election Commission during security review.

92,500 members of the army and navy to be deployed.

High concerns due to prison escapees and weapons at large during September violence. Approximately 1,200 weapons 5,000 escaped prisoners

International Support

Negative by the West, support from Russia and its allies

Positive

Positive

Regional Support

Mixed – China, India Support polls, ASEAN bans polls

Positive

Positive

Holding of Polls – Free and Fair

Negative

Likely

Highly Likely

Post Polls prognostication

Military dominated USDP could form government, however likely to lead to attenuation of violence.

Cannot be predicted for now [12 Nov]

Cannot be predicted for now [12 Nov]

Overall political & Security impact

Contested and highly resisted first phase of polls likely with outcomes predetermined, military will declare success and claim restoration of democracy.

Violence will continue across the country with limited assurance of holding of next phase of the polls.

There is an opportunity for fundamental change in Bangladesh, however continued political violence and elitocracy may deprive the public real change.

Major transformation in political spectrum is not anticipated with weak, institutions,  factionalism and political culture of violence

Overall political transformation will be evident if political parties are willing to transfer power to younger leadership. A more of the same scenario may only lead to another wave of resistance by the Gen Z and other politically marginalised elements.  

Related Research

 

Join our mailing list for updates on publications and events

Thanks for submitting!

2196, B 2, Near Muskaan School Vasant Kunj New Delhi 110070

+91-9899692368

© 2023 by Security-Risks, Designed & Developed by Inkryptis Design Studio

bottom of page