top of page

Agnipath Experiment: Need for a Decent Burial

3 hours ago
4 min read
Image Source Wix Library - Annotated
Image Source Wix Library - Annotated

The Agnipath experiment which began about five years ago continues to be in the experimental stage with announcement by the Chief of Defence Staff General N Raja Subramani on November 4, a Cabinet proposal that creates a pathway for all Agniveers to be absorbed in Defence Forces.


 A Ministry of Defence Press release on the same day stated that “an objective assessment in terms of organisational requirements and operational efficiency has brought out the outstanding performance of Agniveers in terms of skills, motivation levels, physical fitness and technological prowess”.


“As envisaged earlier, based on merit, 25% of Agniveers will be offered regular employment in the Defence Forces,” says the release in continuation of the original proposal.

As per the review carried out, “remaining 75% Agniveers, on the recommendations of the Indian Defence Forces, another engagement period of 2 years has been approved by the Cabinet. After completion of this two-year engagement period, all Agniveers will be offered enrollment as regular soldiers subject to their willingness and their meeting selection criteria”.


Thus, “With the introduction of another engagement period of two years followed by induction of all Agniveers as regular soldiers, the Cabinet has created a pathway for absorption of all Agniveers into Defence Forces”.


The Hindustan Times reports that 18,300 Agniveers were to be discharged between mid-November and December 31, or three-fourths of the 24,400 recruits inducted into the Army, Air Force and Navy in the first round of recruitment under the new scheme.


This is in effect partial restoration of the original scheme of recruitment in the armed forces - permanent enrolment from the very outset. While there is no official clarity on the terms and conditions on which the first and the second lot will continue in service, it is a tacit acceptance that the original proposal of 25 % in and the rest out after four years has not worked out.


The reasons for the review of the scheme are not far to seek and had been flagged by many during the short debate prior to the introduction.


Military profession even as a soldier, sailor or airman is a highly skilled vocation. Even an infantry soldier who is many time wrongly seen as the least technically qualified person in the armed forces must acquire over 100 skills – the figure may surprise many. It is this expertise that ensures that the soldier can survive in the face of enemy fire, save lives of his comrades in arms and facilitate conduct of the mission.


To acquire these skills takes time, a good infantry soldier will require at least five years of intense training – individual [personal skills] and collective – at the subunit and the unit level.  It is believed that other trades – in the army as well as the navy and the air force have similar nuances.


Discharging 75 % of the Agniveers after four years when they are about to cross the threshold of efficiency is thus discharging individuals about to peak.


The logic was to keep the profile of the military young and possibly cut back on the pension bill which is no doubt a burden on the exchequer. But maintaining large militaries can never by easy on the budget and nations must be willing to spend for their sovereignty and safety of their citizens particularly when India faces myriad challenges that we  are reminded of each day.


 Agnipath scheme represented the ultimate, “commodification,” of the soldier – converting an individual at arms an “item” that can be hired, packaged as a semi trained product and ‘sold,’ in the market to others who are in need of it varying from the Central Police Organisations to private security agencies.


The Cabinet has done well to review the scheme. For governments it is always difficult to reverse a decision given that there is an impact on credibility of the establishment having reverberations in democracies with unforeseen consequences. No amount of a narrative deploying influencers who are willing to parrot the official line can turn a bad scheme into a good one.


Had the Scheme been introduced after intense public debate by first publishing a draft and then taking views into account this would have evolved into a mature proposal in the interest of the services as well as the men who join it, things would not have come to pass.


No doubt such a pathway would have been a long one. Yet while the government is willing to publish a draft of a Defence Acquisition Procedure take the views of the services, the industry and the academia, a far more important element in security the man behind the machine was not debated prior to introduction of the Agnipath Scheme.


This is a reminder that while technology is important it must be subservient to the personnel and never the other way round. In fact, over emphasis on absorption of modern technologies ranging from Artificial Intelligence to Quantum Computing etc which are being sermonised at every major defence industry forum while neglecting men will be the bane of the Indian military in the future.


The means to reduce the pay and pension bill is to optimise conflicts to those that are essential rather than seeing an enemy behind every bush. This is more so applicable in the internal context where excellent results have been achieved over the years, but the roots of disaffection be it in Jammu and Kashmir or Manipur continue to tie up thousands of soldiers and policemen. These conflicts are ripe for political resolution which will reduce the manpower burden hugely.


A corrective can be now applied covering many of these factors above – from an understanding that soldiering is a highly skilled profession which cannot be commodified to putting the man in front of the technology and not the other way round. This is the essential lesson of contemporary wars be it Ukraine or Iran which have been ignored while drones and missiles taking the front stage indicating misplaced priorities. Soldier is God is a motto prominently displayed in many Indian army units, and it could be true of possibly warships as well as the Air Force stations as well


Now that the bullet has been partially bitten, hopefully the Agnipath Scheme will be given a decent burial in the days to come and recruitment of soldiers, sailors and airmen for a full term as hitherto fore restored.



Comments


Join our mailing list for updates on publications and events

Thanks for submitting!

2196, B 2, Near Muskaan School Vasant Kunj New Delhi 110070

+91-9899692368

© 2023 by Security-Risks, Designed & Developed by Inkryptis Design Studio

bottom of page