Tuesday 28 June 2016 Home | Sitemap | Contact Us

  Research Papers  |  Books  |  Items
Security Issues South Asia » Terrorism » India – Pakistan - South Asia’s Zero Sum Game
Rahul Bhonsle

Jul 3, 2012

Print Bookmark Email

India – Pakistan - South Asia’s Zero Sum Game

            Much of South Asia’s travails are blamed on the zero sum game between India and Pakistan. Thus when leaders of South Asia, led by the Prime Minister of Bangladesh Sheikh Haseena asked the Indian Prime Minister Dr Man Mohan Singh and then Pakistani Prime Minister Mr Yusaf Raza Gillani to take a quiet walk in the garden in Thimpu during the SAARC summit in 2010 and resolve the differences fresh hopes evoked optimism. This was sustained through the years with the high point being possibility of Most Favoured Nation status accorded by Pakistan to India by the end of 2012 and liberalization of trade including energy as well as the visa regime. Events during June however seem to indicate likelihood of return to the zero sum game, here is why?

             Status quo on two crucial engagements on long standing disputes over alignment of the line of control/international boundary at Siachen and Sir Creek is the first set of events that denoted stalemate in the relations. With over 100 soldiers killed in a snow slide in Siachen, Pakistan had raised the stakes with a flurry of articles indicating necessity for a pull back of troops from eyeball to eyeball confrontation at over 18,000 feet in the Glacier. Pak Army Chief General Kayani seemed to suggest that progress in Indo Pak relations would be based on a breakthrough in Siachen.  For India side without any change in the basic premise, of demarcation, disengagement was not a practical option.

Devoid of a breakthrough in Siachen, Sir Creek remained in the cold freeze. Evidently both sides were not prepared to step up the rapprochement to the next level by resolving the vexatious boundary issue. Opinion makers in Pakistan as Maleeha Lodhi, wrote in the News International, a Jang group newspaper, that given lack of progress in talks at Siachen and Sir Creek, there was no point in continuing the trade track. Ironically the Jang group and the Times of India have launched a joint initiative to improve people to people relations, “Aman ki Asha”.   

Meanwhile there were serious violations of cease fire in the Poonch region of Jammu and Kashmir with mortar firing spilling over for a week. This resulted in blocking cross border movement of people and goods a CBM which had gained much traction.

During the same period, there was political upheaval as Mr Yousaf Raza Gillani was disqualified from the National Assembly by the Supreme Court overturning the ruling of the Speaker of the august legislative body over his indictment in the Swiss reference case. This has reopened the contest between the institutions and political parties with the Army possibly playing a referee or waiting in the wings as per knowledgeable observers. Thus initiatives taken by Mr Gillani and the Pakistan People’s Party President Mr Zardari to improve relations with India are now on the back burner as there is more judicial activism in store for the ruling party.

The severest blow however came with interrogation of the Indian terrorist Abu Jundal alias Sayeed Zabiuddin Ansari who had been operating for the Lashkar e Taiyyaba in Pakistan. Jundal reconfirmed involvement of state actors in that country in the 26/11 Mumbai terror attack.  The ghosts of terrorism thus again haunt Indo Pakistan relations and unless there is a fundamental shift in strategic discourse between the two major states in South Asia, the zero sum game is likely to continue

Related Tags


Related Article

India Hyperactive Polity Overheating Economy
Timeline and Issues for Dialogue India, Pakistan
India: Towards the Super League
Indo Pakistan Relations in Limbo
India's Official Take on Indo Pakistan Talks
Pakistan in 2006 A Nation in Crisis
Zardari Visits Ajmer Delhi Soft Indo Pak Diplomacy
Timeline & Issues Dialogue India Pakistan
Indo Pakistan Foreign Ministers Talks – Running While Standing
INDO PAKISTAN Relations Issues
Is Prime Minister Man Mohan Singh Recalibrating Pakistan Policy?
India Defence Developments 2006
India: Perils of Divisive Polity
Challenges of Indo Pakistan Relations
Indo Pakistan Talks the Complete Official Rundown
Modi Defence and Security Policies – Exploiting the “Triple Whammy”


Article by Same Author

Pak Elections – Economy, India Pak Relations, Provinces and the Army
Trends in Operations in Afghanistan in 2012
Maldives Presidential Elections: Political Instability May Continue
Pakistan Exercise Azm-e-Nau 4: Checkmating India’s Cold Start?
Talk Asian Cooperative Security and Not Just Balancing China
Aero India 2015: The Lure for Foreign Companies?
Why Army Aviation will be Most Sought After in Aero India 2015?
India’s Disaster Vulnerability and Response
Indian Army's Battle for Hearts and Minds in Srinagar
Terrorism in India: Demand and Supply Dynamics
Pakistan: Sharif versus Sharif Round Two
Perils of Measuring Instability or Peace Uniformly
Trade versus Security – India’s China Dilemma?
Bhutan China Relations and India
India’s Self Created Bhutan Conundrum?
Could Plan B for Rafale be Su 30 MKI?
Nawaz Sharif’s T2 Dilemma with India
PM Modis Twitter Diplomacy: The Pluses and Minuses
Indigenisation of Capital Acquisitions
NSCN IM Blames Government for Failure of Peace Talks
Army Command Exit Model: Stepping Back to Step Forward -The Way Ahead
India – China – Next Steps to Boundary Management
Pakistan Army: Returning to Political Centre Stage?
Reducing Vulnerability of India’s Terror Fault lines
Iran's Presidential Election: Implications for Indo Iranian Relations
Gaza: India Must Stand for Proportionate Response
Night of January 16th
BRICS: Towards Political and Security Muscle?
Obama II & Indo US Defence Relations
Herat Indian Consulate Attack: Joining the Dots
Priotise Decapacitation of Lashkar E Islam in Kashmir
Civil Military Relations in Pakistan: Memogate
Nawaz Sharif’s China Visit: Comfort Away from Home
Pentagon 2012 Report on China: PLA’s Rapid Modernisation
Talking to Pak without a Counter-Terror Strategy
Is India’s Defence Acquisition Process Maturing?
PM Modi visit to Vikramaditya: Signaling Hard Power
Daw Aung Suu Kyi: The Liberal Pragmatic
Jointness: Single Point Defence Agenda for Modi Government
China and India: Rational Irrationality & Parallel Pathways
India China Border Stand Off - De-escalate, Delineate and Set Norms
Kashmir Terrorism Uptick: Portends or Empty Threats?
Security Imperatives of Indo Pakistan Dialogue
Concerns over Implementation of Offset Policy
Pakistan Elections & Indo Pakistan Relations
Demilitarisation in Kashmir: Technology a Partial Answer
India: Avoiding Counter Terrorism Complacency Post Bhatkal and Other Arrests
Manmohan Visit to Washington: Rejuvenating Indo US Relations
Pakistan Elections: Rush of the Fortune Seekers
India Japan Annual Summit: Defining a New Strategic Axis

Y! MyWeb

Home | Security Trends South Asia | Security Issues South Asia | Top Stories | Publication  | Events | About Us | Contact Us | Disclaimer  | Privacy Policy
© Copyright of Security-risks 2016 All Rights Reserved Web Design India Internet
In case you come across any suspicious activity, any suspicious movement or have any information to tell to the Anti-Terror Squad, please take a note of the new ALL INDIA TOLL-FREE Terror Help-line "1090". Your city's Police or Anti-Terror squad will take action as quickly as possible. Remember that this single number 1090 is valid all over India. This is a toll free number and can be dialled from mobile phones also. Moreover, the identity of the caller will be kept a secret.

Please try to make aware each and every citizen of India about this facility.

BC is the westernmost of Canada's provinces and is famed for its natural beauty.Vancouver is BC's largest city.