Thursday 2 October 2014 Home | Sitemap | Contact Us

  Research Papers  |  Books  |  Items
Security Issues South Asia » Terrorism » Terrorism in India: Demand and Supply Dynamics
Rahul Bhonsle

Mar 4, 2013

Print Bookmark Email

Terrorism in India: Demand and Supply Dynamics

India has made remarkable progress in countering terrorism and insurgency in the country over the past six decades plus after independence. Contrary to popular perception the Indian state’s response to what is known variously as low intensity conflict, asymmetrical wars and so on has been effective in containing conflicts ranging from Jammu and Kashmir in the North West to Nagaland, Manipur and Assam in the North East. Most significantly the redux of Naxalism has been limited to the jungles of Central India. In some cases the spectre of terrorism and militancy has been neutralized be it Punjab or Mizoram through some deft political initiatives that followed containment of violence. Post Mumbai 26/11 an attempt to create a credible counter terror architecture has resulted in admirable results the debate over National Counter Terrorism Centre (NCTC) notwithstanding.

Yet serial bomb blasts in Hyderabad on 21 February which saw the loss of 16 lives is a grim reminder that India has failed to imbibe the lessons from past successes and build on the same to combat new challenges in the post modern nontraditional security spectrum in real time. A demand and supply dynamics is one way at looking at the challenges, responses and the way ahead.

The demand for terrorism as a political tool for overcoming grievances or attaining aspirations has been reasonably contained be it in Kashmir, the North East or Naxal affected states, with some enlightened development initiatives though implementation is poor as the peripatetic Rural Development Minister Mr Jairam Ramesh has never tired of accepting publicly. There is extremely low demand for religious extremist terror in the country which is largely a tribute to inter communal harmony which is ingrained in the pluralist ethos. The fatwa issued against terrorism by our Muslim clergy from Deoband, the base from which the Afghan Taliban also draw their ideology is laudable.

Yet terrorists do not require mass support for their acts and the tenets of Foco and Detonator theories of insurrection denote that societal rebellions can be triggered by through a narrative of imagined grievances. When there is a state in the neighbourhood namely Pakistan which follows a policy of active support to terrorism, in which terrorist groups and leaders can openly hold meetings and make public speeches even though some of them as Hafeez Saeed are banned by the sole super power the United States, demand for terrorism will continue to be generated in India in the near future.

The internal dynamics of demand for terror rests in the narrow political gains which overlook the fact that no organization operating overtly much less a political party, community or religion can be blamed for actions of deviants who form the smallest fraction of its constituents. These on the other hand create a sense of grievance in the section on both sides of the social divide to create demand for terror. The moot point is that the so called, “Islamic and Hindu,” terrorism much like, “Sikh,” or, “Kashmiri,” terror has no basis and any labeling has to be considered with due caution most importantly by those who hold high positions of power be it ministers or political leaders. Blame the deviants not their mother organization unless it is an active sponsor of terror as the Jamaat ud Dawa in Pakistan and its violent arm Lashkar e Taiyabba.

Supply side dynamics factors which contribute to operational capabilities is also of great concern for India. The Pakistan factor has been outlined and it is well understood that unless there is a fundamental shift in state policy in that country to stop the use of terror as a strategic tool, continued support to groups acting against India can be anticipated for only limited resources have to be employed and it is also completely deniable, apprehension of Ajmal Kasab notwithstanding. This would imply that terrorist groups as the Indian Mujahideen will have continuous supply of funds, sanctuaries, training and motivational support to conduct acts as the Hyderabad serial blasts. Continued diplomacy bilateral, regional and global is one tool that will have to be applied.

Curbing the supply side also involves a strong counter terrorism posture in the country, an area in which despite some remarkable results there are many deficiencies. While the core focus has to be in building capacity at the local level through an ability of continuous surveillance, monitoring and proactive intervention through human and technical means there is far too much attention devoted to organizations as National Counter Terrorism Centre (NCTC).

There is no doubt that NCTC is required but only after there is adequate capacity at the city level not before it. For instance placing a network of CCTV cameras at vulnerable locations should have been a priority but there is limited progress in major cities more over use of these for proactive spotting of terrorist activity as planting of bombs is lacking and there is more focus on use during investigation. Thus there are fundamental issues of prioritization which will have to be addressed and the local given more important than the state and the state over national. Creating a Hyderabad or Andhra Counter Terrorism Centre or Mumbai and Delhi Counter Terrorism Centre should be priority which can be linked to the NCTC. A bottom up approach may pay greater dividends including lesser political resistance than a top down one. State police in India are capable as the Andhra Greyhounds have demonstrated in meeting the challenge of Naxalism, however it is apparent that the same force has completely failed on the front of urban terror.

Intelligence and investigation are other key areas where there have been major deficiencies thus the same names of Bhatkal brothers et al keep cropping up after every serial blasts in the country. Obviously successful penetration of the Indian Mujahideen has been lacking and while occasionally cells have been unraveled the top tier remains oblivious given that these may be operating from outside India using modern media tools to advantage. Turf wars is also a bane and formation of the National Investigation Agency has not resulted in corresponding benefits to counter terrorism in the hinterland. Containing the flow of money, arms, movement and so on are other issues that are needed to curb the supply.

Most importantly a comprehensive counter radicalization programme in the core areas from where religious terror is seen to emanate to include Maharashtra, Karnataka, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Madhya Pradesh and so on needs to be carried out so that the exposure to even the miniscule minority to fundamental violent ideology is curbed.

Today’s terror is striking at the very roots of progress in India, the economy and exploiting the fault lines in society be it ethnic or communal. Curbing demand and supply is one way at looking at counter terrorism, whatever model is used urgency in action is underlined.

Related Tags



 

Article by Same Author

Pak Elections – Economy, India Pak Relations, Provinces and the Army
Concerns over Implementation of Offset Policy
Maldives Presidential Elections: Political Instability May Continue
Tracking South Asia Through the Decade
India China Relations – Dramatic Turnaround Post Depsang
What to Expect of Defence Budget 2014- 15?
Pakistan Army: Returning to Political Centre Stage?
India’s Disaster Vulnerability and Response
Civil Military Relations in India: In Times of Change
Afghanistan: Afghan Army Emerging From Shadows of NATO?
India: Avoiding Counter Terrorism Complacency Post Bhatkal and Other Arrests
Kashmir Terrorism Uptick: Portends or Empty Threats?
India Cyber Security: Need for Robust Approach
Indian Army: Officer Men Relations the Missing Links
Is Pakistan Army Launching Operations in North Waziristan?
Assam: Peace Moves and Tribulations
Herat Indian Consulate Attack: Joining the Dots
Bhutan China Relations and India
Pakistan’s National Security Dilemma: Prioritising Internal Security
Naxal Attack on Congress Leaders: Need for “Security Culture”
Talk Asian Cooperative Security and Not Just Balancing China
Boeing’s First India Defence Contract Challenge
France Emerging as Third Pole In Defence Co-Operation with India
How Relevant is the UNMOGIP- UN Observer Mission in India and Pakistan
Military and Media Establishing Positive Relations
India Japan Annual Summit: Defining a New Strategic Axis
China and India: Rational Irrationality & Parallel Pathways
A Threat to Karzai’s Power Base?
Inter Community Relations in South Asia
Is Afghanistan Turning a New Leaf?
India China Fruitful Engagements
Pakistan – A Turbulent Beginning to 2013?
Countering the Indian Mujahideen: Leader Decapacitation
Pakistan Exercise Azm-e-Nau 4: Checkmating India’s Cold Start?
India’s Bangladesh Dilemma Gets More Complex
India – Pakistan - South Asia’s Zero Sum Game
Underlying BDCA Message – exercise restraint – Leadership to Military
Reducing Vulnerability of India’s Terror Fault lines
FDI in Defence: Jaitley Empowers Indian Defence Industry
BAT Actions on LOC: Tactics with Strategic Impact
US Strengthening Security Partnership With Bangladesh
India’s Asia Pacific Rebalancing?
India’s Defence Budget 2014-15 – Expect a 15 - 20 percent Hike
Defence allotments remain in estimated range
Can India Do Without BAE Light Howitzers?
Pakistan’s Coming Civil Military Standoff?
Pakistan Elections: Rush of the Fortune Seekers
PM Modi visit to Vikramaditya: Signaling Hard Power
India’s Final Defence Budget 2014-15: Continuing Challenges to Modernisation
Ukraine and Crimea: India Retains Balance

 
ADD TO:
Blink
Del.icio.us
Digg
Furl
Google
Simpy
Spurl
Y! MyWeb






Home | Security Trends South Asia | Security Issues South Asia | Top Stories | Publication  | Events | About Us | Contact Us | Disclaimer  | Privacy Policy
© Copyright of Security-risks 2014 All Rights Reserved Web Design India Internet
In case you come across any suspicious activity, any suspicious movement or have any information to tell to the Anti-Terror Squad, please take a note of the new ALL INDIA TOLL-FREE Terror Help-line "1090". Your city's Police or Anti-Terror squad will take action as quickly as possible. Remember that this single number 1090 is valid all over India. This is a toll free number and can be dialled from mobile phones also. Moreover, the identity of the caller will be kept a secret.

Please try to make aware each and every citizen of India about this facility.

BC is the westernmost of Canada's provinces and is famed for its natural beauty.Vancouver is BC's largest city.